Wednesday, May 13, 2009
Joe's fight
Joe believes that the only thing worth fighting for is your own life, or something you value more than your life, like the life of the woman you love. However, Joe thinks it’s stupid and hypocritical to fight for someone else’s causes. He believes that if you’re fighting for your native land or democracy you will never be able to collect if you die in the masses. Joe believes that all the politicians and higher up people who tell the “simple people” about fighting for honor, democracy, your country and so on have not actually fought in those conditions. Joe knows that this war isn’t his fight, and he’s wondering why he’s even doing it. Joe values life more than anything, and fighting in this war is contradicting his values.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

4 comments:
I think you did a great job summarizing what exactly was going on. I also agree with you that Joe does value his life more than anything and he is able to have this opinion because of how close to death he really is. BY THE WAY he is missing both legs. :]
Yeah Eli, like Dez, I agree with what you're saying. I think in these blogs everybody agrees with each other. Joe would fight for the people he loves, but he wouldn't take up arms for the upper-classes war, their war, not his. In this instance, you can definitely tell that Trumbo was writing this with the influence of Communist and Marxist ideals affecting his writing.
Joe should not be fighting other people's wars, for it is not right for him to sacrifice his life. He gave up his legs, his arms, his eyes, and almost everything just so he could defend principles such as liberty and democracy. While these are good things to believe in, if one does not care for them, then maybe they should have some right to not fight for them, in relation to Joe. He would rather fight for Kareen, if he had to, than anything else, for anything else seemed pointless to him, for nothing was worth giving up his whole life for.
Wow, there's not much difference between these blogs, now is there? Joe thinks it is illogical for him to fight for something he can't see, something he wouldn't profit from after it is over. It isn't that fighting in the first place was against his morals, its that fighting for something he won't profit from is now against his morals. He originally was drafted, without any idea of who he was fighting, and now he thinks that is reprehensible.
Post a Comment